I understand what you are saying. I am saying it may be a mistake.

What would you have me say so you could understand what I’m trying to tell you?

by this , of this

I understand what you are saying. I am saying it may be a mistake. Regardless of modernity or not (my is not a modern position, by the way) I feel you are are taking a fanciful fictional leap and projecting in a way that may not be helpful, and in fact harmful.

We can talk about dangers lurking. I feel the approach is flawed and therefore dangerous. It is leading down a rabbit hole that is confusing and is a rabbit hole one is unable to get out.

I see problems, problems that have real-world consequences.

Freud, as brilliant that he may have been, had gone down a rabbit-hole.

We both want authenticity. And that is what we are arguing for.